Post by mngiant on Apr 20, 2024 18:49:53 GMT -5
I see a lot of Daniel Jones in JJ Mccarthy. Like Jones, Mccarthy has a strong arm, is a gifted athlete, is a dedicated leader, the hardest worker, very smart and processes information very quickly. Why draft Mccarthy when Daniel Jones is all of those things too? Because the Giants may have ruined Daniel Jones, who has never once played behind a quality OL, injury issues too. In drafting Mccarthy, the Giants would have the opportunity to draft another elite QB prospect but this time the Giants can develop him properly.
In my view, it is either JJ Mccarthy or the WR. The other 3 QBs should be off the board after the first three picks. But Mccarthy will be there at 4 or 5 and the Giants can trade up.
I would not go near the other QBs. Bo Nix--well, Stoney likes him--and that is the kiss of death, LOL. Penix is interesting but probably a bust in the NFL--it will take him forever to adjust to the pro game, just like it took him forever to develop into a quality college QB.
First off, I LOVE the character, Stoney on here, his ACT is solid gold. Now, I agree with you that NYG ruined and broke DJ. But this is where we are going to part ways. I don't believe NYG should bring in another QB, until the O-line can protect them good enough to keep them out of the hospital. In fact if NYG does bring in a new QB, he should be the worst UDFA they can find at a community college, with the O-line charged with keeping him out of the hospital. Once the O-line accomplishes this, then NYG can look at a top prospect QB.