Post by brownelvis54 on Oct 8, 2024 15:38:02 GMT -5
I voted no. Good game. Yes. Jones played well? Yes, but it was one game. And that was against a Seattle team that was plagued with injuries on their defense before that start of the game and raked up more injuries during the game. I think the Giants, and rightfully so will wait until the 17th game to decide if Jones is our starter next season. Where we pick will greatly impact his future as well.
When we pick, and one of these QBs are on the board when its our turn and Dabol feels he could mold the young player, then I thinks he pulls the trigger. An injured prone QB that (so far has been inconsistent) and is older and cost a lot of money V.S. a cheap (5 years) young QB would be hard to pass up
Shedeur Sanders
Jalen Milroe
Carson Beck
Cam Ward
Quinn Ewers
Drew Allar
Jaxson Dart
What’s the hit/miss ratio on QBs though?
Richardson gets hurt every time he gets tackled. Bryce Young lost his starting spot already.
Daniels is the only rookie this year that’s doing well. Williams is struggling, Nix is struggling.
In the short term, we’re almost surely going to get worse at the QB spot if we switch from Jones to a rookie. Maybe it will pay off long term, but frankly I think we’re all sick of losing.
If we can get a veteran with similar or better production than Jones for less money, that’s one thing. I really don’t want a rookie who might be terrible…..or might be good in 5-6 years.