Post by soullessnight on Mar 26, 2018 1:09:09 GMT -5
So i found a few draft report on these guys to put things in perspective.
Darnold
www.nfl.com/draft/2018/profiles/sam-darnold?id=2560057
Rosen
www.nfl.com/draft/2018/profiles/josh-rosen?id=2560059
What strikes me is tgat Darnold is so far ahead than Rosen. Rosen's throwing arm might not ever translate to the NFL based on mechanics alone. AND it might nit ever be correctable.
Also neighter of these draft reports list intanginables...does anyone have a specific game in mind where they might have written something like rothlesburger or Eli?
m.giants.com/news-and-blogs/article-1/Read-Ernie-Accorsis-Scouting-Report-on-Eli-Manning/e83c2019-ed1d-4581-95ab-46
"Carried the ENTIRE team".
www.toledoblade.com/Pro/2004/04/18/Roethlisberger-is-a-hot-prospect.html
Big ben...same thing.
“Most quarterbacks with skills that he has make it big in the pros,” said Buffalo Bills quarterbacks coach Sam Wyche. “There are occasionally some that don't make the transition, but when you break his game down and add his size and intellect, I think he's going to be a very good player.”
Rivers eli and ben reports. Few negatives, everyone agreeed pre draft that each if them would become franchise QBs
scout.com/nfl/Article/2004-NFL-Draft-Quarterback-Top-10-104081983
And here are the draft grades before 2004 AND AFTER.
www.google.com/amp/www.sportingnews.com/amp/nfl/news/eli-manning-ben-roethlisberger-2004-nfl-draft-comparison-giants-steelers-chargers-miami-ohio-ole-miss/1rf05itekw3f412ff1guyojykn
Im sorry but i really hope the giants font pick a QB this draft.
Having alot if QBs enter a draft doesnt make it a "qb rich" draft class.
These QBs draft grades arent even close to that 2004 draft class people are comparing it to. Its all hype to get some young men millions of dollars.
When i see 53.3% of college passes completed, thats a red flag.
You do not draft the second best qb in the draft at number 2 if his actual draft grade says "well in 3 years hell be at starter level".
When i saw wentz play, i KNEW he was going to cause problrms for the giants, when i watch these QBs i dont get that impression.
In a league where tom brady STILL goes to the SB, its hard to believe our QB eho missed ONE GAME due to a benching,is "washed up".
I dont buy it. I hope you guys dont either.
Darnold
www.nfl.com/draft/2018/profiles/sam-darnold?id=2560057
Rosen
www.nfl.com/draft/2018/profiles/josh-rosen?id=2560059
What strikes me is tgat Darnold is so far ahead than Rosen. Rosen's throwing arm might not ever translate to the NFL based on mechanics alone. AND it might nit ever be correctable.
Also neighter of these draft reports list intanginables...does anyone have a specific game in mind where they might have written something like rothlesburger or Eli?
m.giants.com/news-and-blogs/article-1/Read-Ernie-Accorsis-Scouting-Report-on-Eli-Manning/e83c2019-ed1d-4581-95ab-46
"Carried the ENTIRE team".
www.toledoblade.com/Pro/2004/04/18/Roethlisberger-is-a-hot-prospect.html
Big ben...same thing.
“Most quarterbacks with skills that he has make it big in the pros,” said Buffalo Bills quarterbacks coach Sam Wyche. “There are occasionally some that don't make the transition, but when you break his game down and add his size and intellect, I think he's going to be a very good player.”
Rivers eli and ben reports. Few negatives, everyone agreeed pre draft that each if them would become franchise QBs
scout.com/nfl/Article/2004-NFL-Draft-Quarterback-Top-10-104081983
And here are the draft grades before 2004 AND AFTER.
www.google.com/amp/www.sportingnews.com/amp/nfl/news/eli-manning-ben-roethlisberger-2004-nfl-draft-comparison-giants-steelers-chargers-miami-ohio-ole-miss/1rf05itekw3f412ff1guyojykn
Im sorry but i really hope the giants font pick a QB this draft.
Having alot if QBs enter a draft doesnt make it a "qb rich" draft class.
These QBs draft grades arent even close to that 2004 draft class people are comparing it to. Its all hype to get some young men millions of dollars.
When i see 53.3% of college passes completed, thats a red flag.
You do not draft the second best qb in the draft at number 2 if his actual draft grade says "well in 3 years hell be at starter level".
When i saw wentz play, i KNEW he was going to cause problrms for the giants, when i watch these QBs i dont get that impression.
In a league where tom brady STILL goes to the SB, its hard to believe our QB eho missed ONE GAME due to a benching,is "washed up".
I dont buy it. I hope you guys dont either.